I bought the Commuter case for my iphone 5 the same day i bought my phone. I had never had an Otterbox, but my brother swore by them. I had the white with the gunmetal grey inner case. The case is not only very cute but its so practical. I drop my phone all the time and not only does the phone not get damaged, the case doesn't either. Also, I'd like to object to the comment below saying the white case got dirty , mine did not, at all. As a matter of fact, Otterbox just replaced my last case because it broke and I just compared the two side by side and there was no difference in color.
One more thing. Otterbox has the BEST costomer service around. If there's something wrong with the prodect let them know and they fix it, no hassle! Never buying anything but Otterbox.